In the course of dissertation service, the author can only analyze one part of the work – the skill of the paper writer or performer, the work of the director, etc. However, he can expand the subject of his research, consider in a complex the problems associated with the work under discussion, including number and beyond its content. it is impossible to overlook the aesthetic requirements of art proper, let us say more: determining the degree of esthetic value of a work should be the first thing to be criticized.
In preparing the review, you can actively involve elements of historical, psychological, sociological analysis, which, undoubtedly, will make his presentation more relevant and weighty.
Regardless of which way the dissertation service is going, the basis of his speech will be some very definite idea. Therefore, the review in a certain sense is a demonstrative argument, the argumentation of the author’s main idea. This reasoning is based on the external evaluation scheme, which was already mentioned at the beginning of this book. Reasoning about the work of the artist or writer, the reviewer can evaluate it as good or bad, relying on certain consequences that such a work has. These consequences can be very different. The validity of the main thesis depends on the completeness, sufficiency, reliability of the argumentation. What could be the argument in the review? This – knowledge, experience, life observations of the author; the content of the reviewed work, excerpts from it and its form; the attitude to this work of other people, experts, experts; logical consequences of the publication of the work.
The first element of the review is the thesis disclosed in the publication. It is also called the main thesis if the reasoning has a rather complex form and includes some additional theses. The content of the abstract is the result of the research conducted by the author of the review. At the same time, they reflect the author’s worldview, his awareness of this problem, and his understanding of it. Not all theses are usually deployed, filled with a new meaning. Because of this, additional theses can serve as arguments in relation to the main.